I do find it crazy how Bayern have been linked with any semi decent player than can play out wide but Rodrygo.
Maybe things are happening under the hood that we donāt know about. We offered Trossard a new contract yet the club were sounding out that they wanted two new wide players.
Iāll be surprised if heās still here in September, Gunnerblog was saying that we shouldnāt be surprised if a big name leaves to give us the funds to get our targets. Looking around the team, he seems to be the most likely candidate. Hopefully we get a LW in first though, imagine the fuss if the first big transfer is a first teamer being sold, hot on the heels of Partey not re-signing. Ouch.
We shouldnāt sell him. Heās the only player in our squad who can actually run into space on the break.
If we sell him we might actually have the slowest midfield and attack in the league.
2 Likes
If we sell him, the hope is we replace him with someone better, so it shouldnāt be a problem. I would rather keep him as well but heās hit his ceiling and the chances of him getting better seem low so I am quite okay with getting someone new.
Even if we get someone better he isnāt the one that should be sold, at least not yet
Trossard is the one who should depart in that scenario, heās served his purpose.
If we do actually sign an upgrade Martinelli should be the backup for at least the next season, perfectly fine to let him go next summer if they find a replacement rather than giving him a new contract (makes sense actually) but at least he has the required physical tools, Trossard is slow AF and has poor athleticism.
3 Likes
Again, I donāt disagree but neither of them move the needle for us much next season. So if it takes selling Martinelli to get a player who does, then am all for it. Iād rather keep him and get a new player but we donāt might not have the money to do that as Trossard wonāt fetch us much.
We shouldnāt have to sell Martinelli to do so really
We spent nothing in January and barely anything last summer
3 Likes
I donāt know man. The way we are moving in this window, it feels like we donāt have a lot to work with. We should be keeping Partey but it looks like we might not, reportedly because of his wage demands. And now we seem to be open to selling Martinelli when Trossard is the one that should go.
It could also just be a case of us wanting to get some of the big signings done before going all out in the market, but am not so confident. Ideally, we sell Zinny, Trossard, Nelson and keep the reset of the squad, and add an experienced striker, a left winger, a second striker who can be a project.
3 Likes
You may be right about the tight budget and if thatās the case then stick a fork in the supposed title ambitions right now
Because weād be beyond cooked
1 Like
I disagree with the budget angle.
If anything this would suggest an preference (of which thereās plenty evidence) for a small squad. Which would be a grave error.
1 Like
Weāve failed to win the title because of a lack of quality and injuries to key attacking players, so selling one of the better players like Martinelli, to then replace him with an inconsistent player like Rodrygo, whoās never played In the PL, isnāt strengthening at all.
Martinelli is still young and despite some poor performances, would be a very good squad option, especially when itās obvious we lack depth upfront.
Just replacing Martinelli is pointless because if Rodrygo is injured or out of form, then weāll have only Trossard as cover so we need to strengthen our attack with top quality first team players, as well as decent players on the bench who can compete with them.
1 Like
https://x.com/JacobsBen/status/1939034098171027471
MARTINELLI!!!
ā¬90m and heās yours lads.
ā¬85m for Diaz is exactly the kind of transfer these fucks always seem to luck into.
5 Likes
I donāt think this is any time to reverse a worrying trend under Wenger of frequently selling our best players. The last time we sold a top quality first team regular was Alexis Sanchez, since then weāve strengthened without losing players that make a difference.
Xkaka and Partey are the ones that come closest and they were end of contract situations. I would have tried to keep both for another season but, theyāre humans who wanted a new challenge and a good final salary.
Selling Martinelli after one underwhelming season is bonkers.
1 Like
Two underwhelming seasons post 22/23 imo.
9 Likes
For the right money, anyone is for sale. Especially someone not looking up to it for 18 months.
I like martinelli as a squad player and think he can be better again but, if they drop a 250m bid for saka, he could also probably go. Much rather a stupid deal for gabi or trossard obviously.
7 Likes
Also Martinelli is nowhere near one of our best players. If he was, we wouldnāt be seeking to demote him to the bench for one of the new players weāve been linked with.
Itās about time we start bringing in proper money for our wantaways.
Thereās certainly players in the team that I consider untouchable. Martinelli may have been one 2-3 years ago. He isnāt one anymore.
Obviously my preference is to keep him, even as backup in case we sign a new starting left winger. but if a massive Saudi offer(over Ā£70m) arrives, it would be something to consider.
Heās not been the same since Xhaka left.
SInce then heās been served on the left side of midfield by Rice, Merino, Havertz and Trossard. Meanwhile on the hand side right, mostly Odegaard supplying Saka.
Maybe his loss of consistency is a him problem, maybe itās also the lack of consistent partnerships. When heās on his game, when Merino gave him the perfect ball in Madrid, he scored a brilliant goal.
Martinelli started dropping off with Xhaka in the side.
He had a hot 3-4 months ahead of that World Cup in 2022 but Iād say since 2023 he has been on a steady decline.
I think part of it is teams figuring him out and him not developing at the rate youād expect him to.
Still a good player, and could still be dangerous in certain contexts but heās not proven to be someone that should be a starter week in week out.
1 Like