I think both aren’t good. PES has many flaws, feels like an outdated game. Interface, network connectivity, myClub, even Master League is a bit dodgy nowadays. Gameplay alone can’t save a game, for me.
FIFA just edges it, but it’s far from great. It’s pretty much FIFA 17 with minor changes, it’s almost like you head into settings and tweak the sliders, haha. I only play Career mode and it’s ridiculous how little EA care about it. It’s all about FUT.
Gone are the times of PES5 and 6. Those were the proper football gaming days.
Nowadays it’s all about the online coin-based cash cows FUT and myClub. Not for me.