-
Silver member
FIFA 13
Probably deserved to be lol'd at for making this thread this early but I was just looking through our starting 11 on FIFA 12 (with the inclusion of Podolski) and was wondering what rating I would give them on FIFA 13 and what I think EA will give them, and because the current campaign has almost come to an end there's not alot our players can do to heavily swade their future rating on the game so I thought fuck it.
Starting 11 + FIFA 12 ratings..
GK: Wojciech Szezeney (80)
RB: Bacary Sagna (83)
CB: Laurent Koscielny (80)
CB: Thomas Vermaelen (82)
LB: Kieran Gibbs (75)
RCM: Alex Song (82)
LCM: Mikel Arteta (81)
CAM: Jack Wilshere (82)
RW: Theo Walcott (82)
ST: Robin van Persie (88)
LW: Lucas Podolski (83)
What I think they should get..
GK: Wojciech Szezeney (81/82)
RB: Bacary Sagna (84/85) +1/2
CB: Laurent Koscielny (82) +2
CB: Thomas Vermaelen (82) 0
LB: Kieran Gibbs (76/77) +1/2
RCM: Alex Song (83/84) +1/2
LCM: Mikel Arteta (82) +1
CAM: Jack Wilshere (82) 0
RW: Theo Walcott (83) +1
ST: Robin van Persie (89) +1
LW: Lucas Podolski (83) - N/A
What I think EA will give them..
GK: Wojciech Szezeney (81)
RB: Bacary Sagna (84)
CB: Laurent Koscielny (81)
CB: Thomas Vermaelen (82)
LB: Kieran Gibbs (76)
RCM: Alex Song (83)
LCM: Mikel Arteta (82)
CAM: Jack Wilshere (82)
RW: Theo Walcott (83)
ST: Robin van Persie (88)
LW: Lucas Podolski (82)
Couple of things I want to see happen...there are more but I've reached my typing limits and I just cant be bothered to continue for much longer lol..
- Robin van Persie to an 89. He's always been a decent player but after this season's performances and results (goals/assists) he has to be right up there with the best 5 or so players in the world right now, and whilst 88 is still a great rating, there's players with that rating who haven't performed as well as him or who are regarded as one of the very best in world football at this moment in time.
- Koscielny's speed needs to be fixed, it's way too low. Him and Verms also need a badge to their name like tackling or tactician.
- Van Persie deserves the gold complete forward badge. He's currently got clinical finisher and distance shooter, but he could quite easily be given the poacher or dribbler one to get him that complete forward badge.
Share your thoughts bitches, oh and if you're going to give two sets of ratings like I have (what you think they deserve and what you think EA will give them..) then don't be biased and be honest.
I tried to be as honest as possible but I've still given the majority of the starting 11 extra points when it' highly likely, knowing EA/FIFA, only a few of them will be improved.
-
OA Reserve
Nice post :P, Has anyone else noticed how biased FIFA 12 is towards all the "Super Clubs" (Man City, Real Madrid, Barcelona, etc..).
I guess FIFA think it's logical that if a ball is played over the top to Walcott and it lands just outside the box with Walcott 10 yards away and Joe Hart(SUPERMAN!) is starting on his goal line, Hart can beat Walcott to the ball with AT LEAST 5 yards to spare! 
The game is fucking broken IMHO.. But I still play it i dno why
-
Lul Lu Lu, Lukas Podolski!
I agree with your ratings street, fifa give teams like Liverpool better players than us a bloody joke.
Metalblade I am just like you, worst Fifa for years IMO but still play it because it's the latest and nothing better. The game's mechanics are all over the place. Sometimes good a lot of the time bad.
Worst thing is is the impact engine when players colide for no reason and cost you a goal by playing everyone onside from the penalty area and or they take 2 minutes to get up. I hope the next Fifa sorts this.
-
Silver member
Just played around with our starting 11 on FIFA 12 to get their FIFA 13 ratings..
What I think they should get bar Van Persie's 90 rating which I think should be 89, though the general opinion on his rating on FIFA 13 from the EA forums is 89/90 so you never know.

What I think EA/FIFA will give them, though I still think I've been a little kind so I wouldn't be surprised if they were even lower..
-
OA First Team